CESTAT Rulings


Banner advertising on website not 'BAS' pre-May 2006; Revenue's appeal meritless 

Banner advertising on e-Bay website taxable only under “Sale of advertising space and time service” w.e.f May 1, 2006, not “Business Auxiliary Services” (BAS); Since advertisin...View More

Funskool board games classifiable as 'toys/puzzles' or 'games'?, Bench refers to President 

2 Member CESTAT Bench refers classification dispute of Funskool board games viz. Chip N Dale, Duck Tale Disney, Fox & Geese and Rally to CESTAT President for determination; Issue pertained to clas...View More

Allows input service credit on storage shed construction within factory premises

CESTAT allows input service credit on construction / erection / fabrication of temporary shed for storage of cement and steel inside factory premises; Services in relation to setting up, modernis...View More

Captive consumption amongst sister concerns 'revenue-neutral exercise'; Credit on electricity available 

CESTAT cites 'revenue neutrality' to allow proportionate input credit on generation and supply of electricity to assessee’s second unit with different Excise registration; Distinguishes Maruti S...View More

'Credit non-availment' condition for GTA abatement applicable to service provider, not recipient 

CESTAT upholds Commissioner (Appeals) ruling, credit availment by ‘service recipient’ no ground to deny 75% abatement benefit on ‘GTA services’; Notification Nos. 32/2004-ST an...View More

Laptop a 'capital good', 'Movability' irrelevant for CENVAT credit 

CESTAT allows capital goods credit on laptop (installed with special software) used to operate aluminium pressing machines in factory; Laptop falls within Chapter 84 of Central Excise / Customs Tariff...View More

Un-availed cash discounts includible in 'Transaction value'; Refers matter to CESTAT President 

Un-availed cash discounts includible in assessable value of cleared goods under new Sec 4 of Central Excise Act; As per ‘Transaction Value’ definition, consideration received at a time oth...View More

Rejects revenue-neutrality argument; Denies GTA credit absent manufacture/duty payment 

CESTAT denies CENVAT credit on transportation of inputs and final products to / from job-workers premises, absent manufacture / duty payment by assessee; Rejects assessee’s contention of revenue...View More

Absent sale, differential CVD credit admissible against BoE, not supplementary invoice 

CESTAT allows capital goods credit of differential countervailing duty (CVD) paid, subsequent to revision of import rates; Rejects Revenue’s contention that since differential duty was paid unde...View More

After Chennai CESTAT, Delhi allows CENVAT Credit refund before registration 

Refund of accumulated CENVAT credit taken prior to obtaining registration permissible under Rule 5 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004; Relies on Karnataka HC ruling in mPortal Wireless Solutions India Pvt L...View More