Supreme Court Rulings


Judges split on evidential value of 'letters' in determing packing bags' returnability

SC bench gives split view on inclusion of price of gunny bags used for packing, in assessable value (AV) of soda ash, differs on interpretation of apex court verdicts in Mahalakshmi Glass Workd (P) Lt...View More

Endorsement on BoE demanding duty, constitutes 'show-cause-notice'; Grants Samadhan Scheme benefit 

SC holds endorsement on Bill of entry (BoE), requiring additional customs duty payment as valid ‘notice of demand’, allows benefit of Kar Vivad Samadhan Scheme provisions for settlement of...View More

Loan acceptance does not make 'job-worker' a dummy unit; Detergent India relied 

SC upholds CESTAT's findings, 'manufacturer' of "AKAI" Color TV sets on job-work basis, not a dummy unit of assessee merely because of acceptance of loan; CESTAT had observed that since 'job-worker' r...View More

Denies 'Project Imports' benefit to Power Plant not meant for general public 

SC upholds rejection of Project Imports benefit under Chapter Heading 98.01 of Customs Tariff Act, on import of Gas Enginator Generating system with accessories and spares for initial setting-up of Po...View More

Absent machinery provisions, assessment proceedings against legal heirs of deceased proprietor unsustainable 

SC quashes Kerala HC Division Bench decision, no assessment proceedings under Central Excises and Salt Act can continue against legal heirs / estate of sole proprietor / manufacturer after his / her d...View More

'Nizral shampoo' a dandruff medicine, not "toilet preparation", exigible to lower duty 

SC rules in favour of assessee, ‘Nizral Shampoo’ for dandruff cure exigible to lower excise duty rate of 16% as “patent or proprietary medicament” under CETH 3003.10 of Central...View More

Quashes demand; Parties to joint venture not "related persons" absent interest mutuality 

SC quashes excise duty demand on sale of tyres exclusively to promoters under joint venture (JV), absent ‘mutuality of interest’ in terms of erstwhile Sec 4(4)(c) of Central Excise Act; Re...View More

Upholds HC order; Circular clarifying taxability of mutual fund distribution commission, illegal 

SC finds no error in AP HC judgment that quashed CBEC Circular dated November 5, 2003 clarifying that commission received by distributors on mutual fund distribution is exigible to service tax as &ldq...View More

Upholds demand; Mounting water purification and filtration system on job-work constitutes "manufacture" 

SC dismisses assessee’s appeals, assembling / mounting various components of water purification and filtration system (WPFS) on job-work basis, amounts to ‘manufacture’ u/s 2(f) of C...View More

Applies Thermax ratio; Extends CVD exemption on import of Nylon Yarn

SC extends exemption from countervailing duty (CVD) payable on import of Nylon Filament Yarn, in terms of Notification No. 6/2002-CE; Sets aside CEGAT view that when credit under CENVAT Credit Rules i...View More